Question 1

What is a green lease in real estate law?

Accepted Answer

A green lease is a rental or lease agreement that legally regulates sustainability goals, such as energy efficiency, resource use, data transparency and ecological standards in building operation.

Question 2

What legal requirements must green lease clauses meet to be effective?

Accepted Answer

Green lease agreements must be specifically designed, particularly with regard to obligations, metrics and legal consequences; non-binding ESG declarations of intent generally have no legal effect.

Question 3

What are the legal differences between a lease agreement and a rental agreement?

Accepted Answer

In the case of a lease, in addition to the granting of use, the use of the yields ("fruits") is also permitted, which is particularly relevant from a legal perspective in agriculture and viticulture.

Question 4

What special features apply to long-term lease agreements in the wine industry?

Accepted Answer

Wine-related lease agreements often involve long terms, management obligations, investments in vineyards, and climate and yield-related risks that must be taken into account contractually.

Question 5

What was the original significance of Section 550 of the German Civil Code (BGB) for long-term lease agreements?

Accepted Answer

Section 550 of the German Civil Code (BGB) meant that long-term leases were considered indefinite and could be terminated prematurely if they were not in writing.

Question 6

What changes have been made to Section 550 of the German Civil Code (BGB) by the Bureaucracy Relief Act?

Accepted Answer

The Bureaucracy Relief Act IV (BEG IV), which came into force on January 1, 2025, replaced the strict written form requirement for long-term commercial leases under Section 550 of the German Civil Code (BGB). Now, text form (Section 126b BGB) is generally sufficient for leases exceeding one year. This means that contracts and amendments can be concluded via legible textual communication (e.g., email, PDF) without requiring a handwritten signature. At the same time, the previous "written form trap"—where the contract was considered indefinite if the form was not adhered to—remains relevant, but is now shifted to text form as the minimum requirement. Existing leases concluded before the law came into effect are generally still subject to the old written form requirement until December 31, 2025; after that date, the new regulation applies to all existing leases.

Question 7

What is the difference between a share deal and an asset deal in real estate?

Accepted Answer

In an asset deal, the property itself is transferred, while in a share deal, shares in the property-owning company are acquired, each with different tax and liability consequences.

Question 8

What legal advantages does an asset deal offer?

Accepted Answer

An asset deal allows for a targeted selection of the assets and liabilities to be transferred, but requires individual transfers and is regularly subject to real estate transfer tax.

Question 9

What risks are particularly relevant in share deals in the real estate sector?

Accepted Answer

Risks primarily consist of existing liabilities, corporate liabilities, legacy tax burdens, and long-term contractual obligations of the project company.

Question 10

When is real estate transfer tax levied on real estate transactions?

Accepted Answer

Real estate transfer tax is levied on the direct acquisition of land as well as on certain transfers of shares in land-owning companies. The following are subject to real estate transfer tax:
A purchase agreement under the law of obligations or another legal transaction that establishes the right to transfer of ownership, as well as the conveyance of title if no prior legal transaction establishing the right to transfer of ownership has occurred, constitutes the basis for assessment. The agreed purchase price is generally the basis for assessment. If the purchase price is subsequently reduced—for example, due to defects, purchase price adjustment clauses, or subsequent agreements—this does not automatically lead to a reduction in the assessed real estate transfer tax. An adjustment is only made upon the taxpayer's express application to the tax authorities and requires that the purchase price change be recognized for tax purposes.

Question 11

What does RETT mean in the context of real estate transactions, and what are RETT blockers?

Accepted Answer

RETT stands for Real Estate Transfer Tax. It is levied not only on the direct acquisition of real estate (asset deal) but also on certain share transfers in real estate-owning companies (share deals) when legally defined shareholding thresholds are exceeded. RETT blockers are corporate structures designed to avoid real estate transfer tax by not reaching or adhering to the relevant shareholding thresholds (especially 90%). Typical examples include shareholding models with multiple shareholders and compliance with statutory holding periods to prevent tax attribution. However, RETT blockers are subject to strict legal limitations: anti-abuse regulations, economic attribution criteria, and stricter shareholding thresholds mean that such structures remain effective for tax purposes only with careful planning and consistent compliance with legal requirements. Defective or purely formal structuring can retroactively trigger real estate transfer tax.

Question 12

What is a sale-and-leaseback transaction?

Accepted Answer

In a sale-and-leaseback structure, a property is sold and simultaneously leased back by the seller to generate liquidity and continue its use.

Question 13

Which legal aspects are particularly relevant in sale-and-leaseback transactions?

Accepted Answer

Key aspects include the coordination of purchase and lease agreements, terms, termination rights, tax classification, and balance sheet effect.

Question 14

What are operating facilities in the context of real estate taxation?

Accepted Answer

Operating equipment consists of movable assets that directly serve the business and are not necessarily considered part of the property for tax purposes. Typical examples of operating equipment include technical systems and machinery (e.g., production machines), conveying and transport systems (e.g., conveyor belts, cranes), technical infrastructure in specialized properties, such as cooling and ventilation systems in logistics or food processing facilities, server racks, busbars, UPS systems and cooling technology in data centers, bottling, pressing, or storage equipment in agricultural and wine-growing operations, and permanently installed but operationally specific systems that do not primarily serve the building's function. The distinction between property components and operating equipment is complex in individual cases but has significant tax and accounting implications, particularly with regard to trade tax, real estate transfer tax, and purchase price allocation.

Question 15

Why can operating equipment be detrimental to trade tax?

Accepted Answer

Certain operating facilities can lead to income no longer being considered asset management income, thus triggering trade tax.

Question 16

What role does power supply play in the development of data centers?

Accepted Answer

The availability of electricity – especially grid connection capacity, redundancies, and supply contracts – is a key location factor. Without a secure power supply, a data center is generally neither economically viable nor permittable.

Question 17

Why is the use of waste heat in data centers gaining legal importance?

Accepted Answer

Waste heat from data centers can be fed into district heating networks or used for adjacent purposes. Legally relevant factors include energy regulations, municipal requirements, and ESG criteria, which are increasingly influencing permits and financing.

Question 18

Why are data centers or development projects often transferred via a share deal?

Accepted Answer

Data centers are typically held through special purpose vehicles (SPVs) due to their complex operational, energy, and contractual structures. A share deal allows for the preservation of existing permits, contracts, and infrastructure connections, but entails increased corporate and tax due diligence requirements.

Question 19

What is a "powered plant" in the context of data centers?

Accepted Answer

A powered plant refers to a plot of land or property where building permits, a secure power supply, and basic technical infrastructure are already in place or have been contractually guaranteed. Such locations are considered particularly promising for development, as key hurdles to data center development have already been overcome.

Question 20

Why do building regulations, power supply and waste heat utilization need to be considered together in data centers?

Accepted Answer

Data centers are highly energy-intensive facilities. Their permitting regularly depends on the alignment of planning permissions, a secure power supply, and waste heat recovery concepts. A lack of coordination can lead to permitting risks, delays, or operational restrictions.

Question 21

Why is the Rhine-Main region particularly attractive for the development of data centers?

Accepted Answer

The Rhine-Main region is considered one of the leading data center locations in Europe, particularly due to the DE-CIX internet exchange point, one of the world's largest. The high network density, low latency, and direct connection to international data streams make the location especially attractive for cloud, hyperscale, and colocation providers. Added to this are a high-performance energy and transportation infrastructure, proximity to financial and business centers, and a comparatively established regulatory and planning environment in the Frankfurt am Main area.

Question 22

How do cloud, hyperscale, and colocation providers differ in their data centers, and which model is particularly relevant for AI?

Accepted Answer

These terms refer to different data center usage and operating models, each with varying degrees of relevance to artificial intelligence (AI): Hyperscale providers operate extremely large, highly standardized data centers with very high power and energy density. They provide the physical infrastructure required for training and operating large AI models (especially GPU/TPU clusters). Due to their scalability, power availability, and cooling capacity, hyperscale data centers form the central foundation for AI. Cloud providers offer AI services as a service, such as computing power, storage, or AI models on demand. Technically, these offerings regularly access hyperscale infrastructure. Cloud models are therefore the access and usage channel for AI, while the actual computing power is provided in the background by hyperscalers. Colocation providers supply space, power, cooling, and network connectivity, while customers operate their own hardware. Colocation is particularly relevant for AI where there is in-house AI infrastructure, specific regulatory or data sovereignty requirements, or hybrid models (on-premises/cloud). For large-scale AI workloads, however, colocation is usually only a supplement, not a driving force. AI is technically based on hyperscale infrastructure, is economically deployed via cloud models, and can be operated in colocation environments as a complementary solution. This classification is crucial for site selection, building regulations, energy supply, and the structuring of data center projects.

Real Estate

Our range of services

Asset classes & operator properties

Who we work for

Our approach

FAQ